Students use commas, whom, which with prepositions and where/when.
Non-definingMy sister, who lives in Spain, is a nurse.
Which = whole ideaHe passed, which surprised everyone.
Prepositionthe person to whom I spoke · the person I spoke to
Where / whenthe city where I grew up · a time when life was simpler
CarefulNo that in non-defining clauses.
02
ExpandGo beyond the core with extra range, structure, models, or useful language.
Expand the idea
Go one useful step further.
Non-defining clauses add extra information and are separated by commas; you cannot use that and you cannot omit the pronoun. In formal English the preposition comes before whom or which. Which can refer to a whole clause. Use where for places and when for times.
Step by step
Build it one step at a time.
1
Is the clause essential?
defining or not
extra 2
Use commas
non-defining
, who lives in Spain, 3
Place the preposition
to whom / who … to
the person I spoke to 4
Choose where / when
place / time
the city where I grew up
03
PracticeTurn understanding into accurate, independent language.
Practice
Try the exercises.
01
1. Choose the best answer.
Choose the best answer.
1.
Correct answerMy sister, who lives in Spain, is a nurse.
2.
Correct answerThe person to whom I spoke was helpful.
3.
Correct answerHe passed the exam, which surprised everyone.
4.
Correct answerThis is the city where I grew up.
02
2. Complete the sentence.
Write one or two words.
1.
Correct answerwho
2.
Correct answerwhom
3.
Correct answerwhich
4.
Correct answerwhen
03
3. Your turn.
Write your own answers.
1.
Answer guideMy brother, who lives in Canada, works as an engineer.
2.
Answer guideThe town where I grew up is small.
3.
Answer guideHe apologised, which I appreciated.
04
UseApply the language in a meaningful speaking or writing task.
Use it
Take it beyond the exercise.
Fact files: students write extra information about celebrities using non-defining clauses.